Recropical Link Cloaking – What you Need to Know
24. Mar 2009 | 26 Comments
We all get link requests, most of them are automated garbage & some are legitimate. Some are also too good to be true.
If it’s the latter then I advise you to look a bit closer at what is being offered as recently I came across a interesting Recropical Link Cloaking tactic.
Don’t think this is a new tactic either, this has been going on for a very very long time.
Setting the Scene
You get an email similar to this one:
Hello,
As I was surfing around Google , I discovered your website: http://www.earnersblog.com/ I am trying to add as many informative websites as possible to my site. Which in turn will benefit my users as well as provide you with relevant traffic to your site. I have a website with about 5,000 – 7,000 people on it per day who fit the same demographic as your site.
If you follow this link, http://www.widgets.com/?pg=2eC4L you will see that I put your link on my homepage.
Some website owners do not like when other sites link to them so I thought I might ask for your review.
Please get back to me when you have a chance, to let me know if the link I have placed suits your needs.
Also if you would like a custom Title for it just send me a email and I will get it updated.Have a good week
Visiting the site in question you’ll notice a few things:
- Decent number of Backlinks
- Minimal Outgoing Links
- Decent Pagerank (3 – 5)
Quite possibly the perfect link exchange? Unfortunately not. Look a bit closer.
The Detail
If you look at the email the URL should have a referral string on it (Something like ?ref= or ?pg=). This either sets a cookie when you click on it or logs your IP (or both) which makes your site “appear in the sidebar”.
Thus very cleverly making you think that the website offering the link exchange does indeed link to you.
There’s a few things you can do here to check:
- Run the referral link through a HTTP Header Checker to see if it sets a Cookie
- Look at your Yahoo inbound links, does the site in question appear? (it may be too soon but worth looking)
- Look at the site through a proxy & remove the ?pg or ?ref from the end of the string (Incase they use IP Tracking & not cookies)
- Clear your cookies & try the site again without the referral path on the end
Very Sneaky
This unfortunately is a very cunning & sneaky tactic to harvest thousands upon thousands of Recropical links. I would imagine that the strike rate doing this is much much higher than just blasting out link requests to everyone in sight.
Be Careful
If you’re contracting an SEO company & they’re using this tactic I’d be very very careful. I’ve seen a number of players that have been branded as unethical by their whole online community for using such tactics.
[Hat Tip]
26 Comments on "Recropical Link Cloaking – What you Need to Know"
somebody
26. Mar 2009, 1:46 am
you can also check the page cache where the link should appear on…
Make Money Online
04. Apr 2009, 2:04 am
This is a very big shame! Trying to do some link building in order to make money online. What a petty to these cunning individuals who hide themselves under the sheet of deceit. I will never ever use this type of service if someone would offer one to me.
data
07. Apr 2009, 6:28 pm
the way to make money online with reciprocal link? There are a lot of thing they can do to get a lot of way to get money with exchange link… they can try backlinks.com maybe… pay for it and then they get the link…
YB
16. Apr 2009, 9:15 am
I think I’m missing something, the email you used as an example is not asking for a reciprocal link. They’re saying that they put a link to your website and are asking if it’s ok and if you want to customize the link title.
How does this hurt you? Did you mean to put a further note in your example that says they will remove the link if you don’t reciprocate? Other than there not really being a link to your site I don’t see how this harvests thousands upon thousands of reciprocal links and scams website owners.
me
19. Apr 2009, 2:26 pm
It works if you link exactly to the page that links to you
Melody
20. Apr 2009, 1:09 pm
If only these people would realize that they would benefit so much more from truthful/ethical marketing tactics..
Chris
20. Apr 2009, 6:53 pm
This kinda thing gives me a hardon, it’s so enterprising / clever.
Shame they didnt come up with a better way to cloak the link you click on.
DK
21. Apr 2009, 2:28 am
A very informative post on the unethical ways of link building. Most of us do delve into such link building requests so minutely and end up at the receiving end. Link building is good but these kind of un-ethical ways to do it is totally unacceptable. SEO and link building are not difficult things if you are ready to put in a bit of hard work in the beginning. The decision on which method to follow will depend upon your goals – are you focused on the short term or, are you long term focused.
Jorge Delgado
02. May 2009, 6:13 am
thanks for the info… i was not aware of that way of link building..(not acceptable)
Jorge
Delta Squadron
11. May 2009, 1:40 pm
Thanks for sharing your ideas. All I know is to cloaking an affiliate link but this ethical. It’s just an effective tactics on how you can gain more buyers unlike with what you are discussing on your post.
Karl Foxley
15. May 2009, 5:07 am
I had one of these emails about three weeks ago. I was fortunate enough to get the heads up about this a few days from a friend…
Thanks for sharing and keeping your readers informed.
Regards,
Karl
El Magnate De Internet
24. May 2009, 9:56 am
This way hurts the trust rank, if you have thousands of new links in a week, the google staff will flag you page, and if they find you are using blackhat SEO, It will be removed from google.
Pacc's Adventures
27. May 2009, 8:49 pm
Thanks for the heads up; my site’s pretty small at this stage but I’d really like to change that, so it’s nice to know if some people are using ‘iffy’ tactics that i should watch out for.
Adscend Media Affiliate Network
02. Jun 2009, 3:14 pm
Very sneaky. I’m always impressed with the ingenuity of shady people…
SEO e-Guide
17. Jun 2009, 11:43 am
Sure somebody can do this method to link building but this is not a good idea nowadays since google algorithm is always changing time to time determining rank of a site.
And yes, now many of search engine will de-index a site which was get hundreds links in a short period time, real fast.
Allan
30. Jun 2009, 12:37 am
Unfortunately this sort of activity discourages legitimate link trading. The lengths some people will go to:(
Eric Silva
11. Jul 2009, 5:28 am
I like this, working all together. It reminds me of Traffic through Association.
Affiliate Marketing Blog
25. Jul 2009, 10:26 pm
Great post it is very sneaky. I get requests all the time too. I am actively looking for people to exchange links with myself. I try and get to know the blogger first and do a good amount of research. I always Google them to find out more, find out what forums they are on etc.
Ian at Daydream Dating
26. Jul 2009, 11:23 am
I’ve also come across a couple of sites hiding their outgoing links from Google but nobody else, i.e. they have code on their site which checks for specific visitors using the user agent string (and maybe also checking the IP address and domain).
As “somebody” mentioned above, the way to check this is to look at the page cache held by the search engine in question and make sure your link is on there. Unfortunately, of course, there is a lag in this page being up to date so you can’t be sure your link is missing until a few weeks after exchanging.
Nate
17. Aug 2009, 2:00 pm
There should be penalties for people that do crap like this. I am extremely grateful to have stumbled upon this. Thanks for the heads up!
Bruce Ziebarth
12. Sep 2009, 1:15 pm
Very interesting scam. I am newer to blogging and was not aware that you could make it look like a link, without it actually being one. Thank you for the article. I now know one more thing to watch out for.
Gary Mchale
20. Sep 2009, 4:07 am
Another black hat SEO tactic uncovered.
Let’s hope google takes this serious and penalizes anyone found doing it by kicking them to the bottom of the pile.
Leave the top spots for hard working affiliates trying to make an honest living.
John Macclain
22. Sep 2009, 12:54 am
First I would like to thanks for sharing.
We should discourages this kind of emails.
Michael Appleton
02. Oct 2009, 4:35 pm
Hey Stuart, some really great information here for people who are unaware of this sneaky tactic. I have had this tried on me and my website countless time, just be aware of anything with a referral string or a URL that ends in anything bar your usual extensions.
Great blog by the way, I am sure I will be back
Finch
14. Oct 2009, 2:10 am
It’s sneaky but I’ve seen quite a bit of this in various forms.
I’ve even received an email which I’m pretty sure was employing the same tactic.
It would be easy to blast the guys as deceitful and unethical – but really? You learn more from innovation like this than you do from a 1000 internet marketers doing things by the book. I’d never criticize somebody for getting creative and pushing the envelope. Especially when I mock newbs for showing no creativity and no determination at the other end of the scale.
you can also check the page cache where the link should appear on…
This is a very big shame! Trying to do some link building in order to make money online. What a petty to these cunning individuals who hide themselves under the sheet of deceit. I will never ever use this type of service if someone would offer one to me.
the way to make money online with reciprocal link? There are a lot of thing they can do to get a lot of way to get money with exchange link… they can try backlinks.com maybe… pay for it and then they get the link…
I think I’m missing something, the email you used as an example is not asking for a reciprocal link. They’re saying that they put a link to your website and are asking if it’s ok and if you want to customize the link title.
How does this hurt you? Did you mean to put a further note in your example that says they will remove the link if you don’t reciprocate? Other than there not really being a link to your site I don’t see how this harvests thousands upon thousands of reciprocal links and scams website owners.
It works if you link exactly to the page that links to you
If only these people would realize that they would benefit so much more from truthful/ethical marketing tactics..
This kinda thing gives me a hardon, it’s so enterprising / clever.
Shame they didnt come up with a better way to cloak the link you click on.
A very informative post on the unethical ways of link building. Most of us do delve into such link building requests so minutely and end up at the receiving end. Link building is good but these kind of un-ethical ways to do it is totally unacceptable. SEO and link building are not difficult things if you are ready to put in a bit of hard work in the beginning. The decision on which method to follow will depend upon your goals – are you focused on the short term or, are you long term focused.
thanks for the info… i was not aware of that way of link building..(not acceptable)
Jorge
Thanks for sharing your ideas. All I know is to cloaking an affiliate link but this ethical. It’s just an effective tactics on how you can gain more buyers unlike with what you are discussing on your post.
I had one of these emails about three weeks ago. I was fortunate enough to get the heads up about this a few days from a friend…
Thanks for sharing and keeping your readers informed.
Regards,
Karl
This way hurts the trust rank, if you have thousands of new links in a week, the google staff will flag you page, and if they find you are using blackhat SEO, It will be removed from google.
Thanks for the heads up; my site’s pretty small at this stage but I’d really like to change that, so it’s nice to know if some people are using ‘iffy’ tactics that i should watch out for.
Very sneaky. I’m always impressed with the ingenuity of shady people…
Sure somebody can do this method to link building but this is not a good idea nowadays since google algorithm is always changing time to time determining rank of a site.
And yes, now many of search engine will de-index a site which was get hundreds links in a short period time, real fast.
Unfortunately this sort of activity discourages legitimate link trading. The lengths some people will go to:(
I like this, working all together. It reminds me of Traffic through Association.
Great post it is very sneaky. I get requests all the time too. I am actively looking for people to exchange links with myself. I try and get to know the blogger first and do a good amount of research. I always Google them to find out more, find out what forums they are on etc.
I’ve also come across a couple of sites hiding their outgoing links from Google but nobody else, i.e. they have code on their site which checks for specific visitors using the user agent string (and maybe also checking the IP address and domain).
As “somebody” mentioned above, the way to check this is to look at the page cache held by the search engine in question and make sure your link is on there. Unfortunately, of course, there is a lag in this page being up to date so you can’t be sure your link is missing until a few weeks after exchanging.
There should be penalties for people that do crap like this. I am extremely grateful to have stumbled upon this. Thanks for the heads up!
Very interesting scam. I am newer to blogging and was not aware that you could make it look like a link, without it actually being one. Thank you for the article. I now know one more thing to watch out for.
Another black hat SEO tactic uncovered.
Let’s hope google takes this serious and penalizes anyone found doing it by kicking them to the bottom of the pile.
Leave the top spots for hard working affiliates trying to make an honest living.
First I would like to thanks for sharing.
We should discourages this kind of emails.
Hey Stuart, some really great information here for people who are unaware of this sneaky tactic. I have had this tried on me and my website countless time, just be aware of anything with a referral string or a URL that ends in anything bar your usual extensions.
Great blog by the way, I am sure I will be back
It’s sneaky but I’ve seen quite a bit of this in various forms.
I’ve even received an email which I’m pretty sure was employing the same tactic.
It would be easy to blast the guys as deceitful and unethical – but really? You learn more from innovation like this than you do from a 1000 internet marketers doing things by the book. I’d never criticize somebody for getting creative and pushing the envelope. Especially when I mock newbs for showing no creativity and no determination at the other end of the scale.
Supporters of the Cause
Popular Articles
- Ultimate Dofollow Social List
- Link Building Guide for 2008
- Become a Digg Power User in 48 Hours
- $800 a Day with Yahoo Answers
- Gmail Power Usage
- How to Work from Home - Efficiently
- Dominate Ebay Affiliate Program
- Making Money with Local Niche Directories
- Quick way to Make money with CPA Offers
- Diggproof & Speed up Wordpress
- Make Money with Clickbank & Articles
Recent Posts
- Recropical Link Cloaking - What you Need to Know
- Twitter me Timbers: 5 Ways to Profit from Twitter
- Sitelinks FAIL
- Looking for a Ruby/Python Developer
- Ultimate Dofollow Social & Link Building List
- Aweber Form Trick to Triple Profits
- How to Apply & get Accepted by Affiliate Networks
- Advanced Forum Link Building
- VPS Optimization Guide
- 13 Smokin Tips to Increase Adwords CTR
Affiliate Tools
- Affiliate Marketing Blogs
- Affiliate Network Reviews
- Web Hosting Reviews
- Affiliate Marketing Tools & Software
Guides / Example Sites
- Link Building Guide
- Discount Vouchers - Pligg
- Credit Cards - Wordpress

Enjoy this post? Get the RSS Feed















Interesting post. I get a large number of link exchange requests for my site and normally ignore them as they are of the spam type. It never amazes me to see how they are thinking of new ways to do this.
I would not employ this on my sites, and would never use a service that offered to do this for me. Great post.